Lake Wobegon Meets Investment Bankers

Investment bankers have you believe every stock is above average. Reality is conflicts of interest make it impossible for them to have it any other way.

a woman

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

In the fictional town of Lake Wobegon, "all the women are strong, all the men are good-looking, and all the children are above average."

In investment banking's version, all stocks are strong, all industries will outperform, and all companies are above average.

That's what Catalpa Capital Advisors found when it sifted through analyst recommendations for each company in the S&P 500:

Source: Catalpa Capital Advisors. Chart re-created by author.

Catalpa elaborates: "The overall rankings show little variation over time. Currently, the median rank for all of the stocks in the S&P 500 is 3.9 [outperform]. Since 2008, the median has ranged between 3.7 and 4.0. Even in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis, analysts ranked most stocks now in the index above average and gave just three stocks a rating below 2 [underperform]."

How'd those recommendations work out? Catalpa did a regression analysis to see how rankings fared against subsequent stock returns. One year out, "consensus analyst ratings for the stocks in the S&P 500 have zero explanatory power." (r-squared of 0.004 for you maths nerds).

Warning: Don't buy these buys

Plenty of other evidence backs this up. One paper by Richard Taffler of the University of Edinburgh found that "new buy recommendations on average have no investment value with over half of such stocks earning negative returns over the following 12 months."

The rare sell recommendation, on the other hand, does have predictive value. Another study found that, even when an analyst has a run of profitable picks, it's impossible to predict future prescience based on past performance. Hot streaks are usually just that: streaks.

What's going on here? The answer isn't as easy as just calling investment bankers an inept group of misguided seers.

Part of investment banking's perma-bull stance has to do with conflicts of interests. Investment banks typically have several functions. One is raising capital for corporations; another is advising investors on the merit of those corporations.

You can see how this relationship can get incestuous: If a bank badmouths a company with a sell recommendation, that company may take its business elsewhere when it needs to raise capital.

Banks say they thwart this conflict of interest with a "Chinese wall" that separates bankers from analysts, but the walls aren't exactly impenetrable, to say the least.

Shoot your career

Analysts may also give rosy recommendations to companies simply to gain access to its CEO. In a world where becoming a good analyst requires prying useful information out of executives, slapping a sell recommendation on a company's stock is a successful way of shooting yourself in the foot.

Just consider the story of David Maris. As Jesse Eisinger of ProPublica writes, Maris, a former Bank of America (NYSE: BAC) analyst, called out the shady dealings of drug company Biovail in 2003.

In hindsight, Maris was exactly right: Biovail was, according to the Securities and Exchange Commission, engaging in accounting fraud.

But his call was so controversial and damaging to Biovail that Maris "was sued, fired and stripped of compensation. He also lost access to the world of bulge-bracket Wall Street, was shunned by some institutional investors, and because of the settlement for which he said he felt he had no choice than to enter, he couldn't sue Biovail to seek vindication."

Analysts can also fall victim to cognitive biases. Stocks are supposed to go up, right? Isn't that the point?

For mostly good reasons, optimism prevails in the stock market. Bearishness is usually contrarian, if not curmudgeonly. Analysts, not surprisingly, latch on to that optimism even when it flies in the face of their own analysis.

One interesting study by a group from Purdue and the University of Texas found that the most bullish recommendations come when investor sentiment is highest, suggesting recommendations may have less to do with discounted cash flow than, say, the number of high-fives on CNBC or Sky News Business.

Just buy what's good for you

What's this all mean for you? The most obvious takeaway is: Don't take investment bank ratings too seriously.

A less obvious takeaway is appreciating the importance of underloved, underfollowed companies. The more analysts who cover a stock, the more recommendations it'll have. Since most of those are likely to be buy recommendations, the odds are that the more followed a company is, the more likely it is to be fully priced.

This doesn't mean you have to stick with obscure small caps no one's ever heard of. The best returns don't necessarily come from great companies, but good companies that happen to be underfollowed.

This article, written by Morgal Housel, was originally published on Fool.com. Bruce Jackson has updated it. The Fool's disclosure policy is a strong buy.

More on ⏸️ Investing

Close up of baby looking puzzled
Retail Shares

What has happened to the Baby Bunting (ASX:BBN) share price this year?

It's been a volatile year so far for the Aussie nursery retailer. We take a closer look

Read more »

woman holds sign saying 'we need change' at climate change protest
ETFs

3 ASX ETFs that invest in companies fighting climate change

If you want to shift some of your investments into more ethical companies, exchange-traded funds can offer a good option

Read more »

a jewellery store attendant stands at a cabinet displaying opulent necklaces and earrings featuring diamonds and precious stones.
⏸️ Investing

The Michael Hill (ASX: MHJ) share price poised for growth

Investors will be keeping an eye on the Michael Hill International Limited (ASX: MHJ) share price today. The keen interest…

Read more »

ASX shares buy unstoppable asx share price represented by man in superman cape pointing skyward
⏸️ Investing

The Atomos (ASX:AMS) share price is up 15% in a week

The Atomos (ASX: AMS) share price has surged 15% this week. Let's look at what's ahead as the company build…

Read more »

Two people in suits arm wrestle on a black and white chess board.
Retail Shares

How does the Temple & Webster (ASX:TPW) share price stack up against Nick Scali (ASX:NCK)?

How does the Temple & Webster (ASX: TPW) share price stack up against rival furniture retailer Nick Scali Limited (ASX:…

Read more »

A medical researcher works on a bichip, indicating share price movement in ASX tech companies
Healthcare Shares

The Aroa (ASX:ARX) share price has surged 60% since its IPO

The Aroa (ASX:ARX) share price has surged 60% since the Polynovo (ASX: PNV) competitor listed on the ASX in July.…

Read more »

asx investor daydreaming about US shares
⏸️ How to Invest

How to buy US shares from Australia right now

If you have been wondering how to buy US shares from Australia to gain exposure from the highly topical market,…

Read more »

⏸️ Investing

Why Fox (NASDAQ:FOX) might hurt News Corp (ASX:NWS) shareholders

News Corporation (ASX: NWS) might be facing some existential threats from its American cousins over the riots on 6 January

Read more »