It's never comfortable buying something after it has fallen sharply.
But that's often when I start paying the most attention.
The Betashares India Quality ETF (ASX: IIND) is down over 20% over the past 12 months, with most of that decline happening recently. That has pushed it toward 52-week lows and raised an important question.
Is this a warning sign, or an opportunity to buy quality at a better price?
Image source: Getty Images
What you're actually buying
One thing I always like to do with exchange-traded funds (ETFs) is look under the hood.
IIND isn't just broad exposure to India. It focuses on higher-quality companies, which is an important distinction.
Its top holdings include Bharti Airtel, Hindustan Unilever, Infosys Ltd (NYSE: INFY), Vedanta, and ICICI Bank Ltd (NYSE: IBN).
That's a mix of telecommunications, consumer goods, financials, industrials, and technology.
What I like about this is that it reflects a broadening Indian economy. It's not just one theme driving growth, but multiple sectors evolving at the same time.
The AI risk is real
That said, there is a genuine risk emerging that investors shouldn't ignore.
According to the Financial Times, advances in artificial intelligence (AI) are starting to raise concerns about India's outsourcing industry, particularly the repetitive, lower-end work that has historically been a major part of the sector.
The article notes that "agentic tools are coming for the repetitive work that was once their bread and butter" and highlights fears that clients may increasingly rely on AI rather than outsourcing providers.
There is also growing uncertainty about whether companies will continue to rely on Indian IT services firms or instead build their own AI capabilities internally.
That's important, because companies like Infosys, one of the IIND ETF's holdings, sit right in the middle of this shift.
Why I still think it makes sense
Even with those concerns, I don't think the investment case falls apart.
India's growth story is much bigger than outsourcing.
The economy is being driven by rising consumption, infrastructure development, financial services expansion, and a growing middle class. Many of the Betashares India Quality ETF's holdings are tied to these domestic trends, not just global outsourcing demand.
There's also an argument that India adapts rather than falls behind.
The same Financial Times piece points out that while lower-end jobs may be at risk, higher-skilled roles and "global capability centres" are expanding, with multinational companies continuing to invest in India's talent base.
So the nature of growth may change, but that doesn't necessarily mean it disappears.
The valuation is more appealing now
The recent pullback is what really gets my attention.
A 20% decline doesn't automatically make something cheap, but it does change the starting point.
You're no longer buying into peak optimism. Expectations have come down, and that can improve long-term return potential if the underlying growth story continues.
For me, this looks like another case where sentiment has weakened faster than the long-term fundamentals.
A long-term and balanced approach
This isn't something I'd expect to rebound quickly.
Emerging markets can be volatile, and themes like AI disruption can take time to play out.
I'd see the Betashares India Quality ETF as a long-term position and one part of a broader portfolio, rather than a standalone bet.
Pairing it with developed market ETFs and Australian shares can help balance out that volatility.
Foolish Takeaway
The Betashares India Quality ETF has fallen to 52-week lows, and there are valid concerns around how AI could reshape parts of India's economy.
But the broader growth story remains intact in my view, and the recent pullback has made the entry point more interesting.
For patient investors, I think it makes sense to consider buying at these levels, as long as it's done as part of a diversified, long-term portfolio.
