Up 178% in a year, why is this ASX All Ords silver share sinking today?

Investors are bidding down this high-performing ASX silver stock today. But why?

Key points
  • Silver Mines shares fell following an update on the Bowdens Silver Project.
  • The NSW Court of Appeal voided the project's approval last year, prompting revised ecological surveys and plans to align with changing regulations.
  • Management is focused on successfully redetermining the project, emphasising commitment to transparency and project merit.

The All Ordinaries Index (ASX: XAO) is up 0.4% today, but ASX All Ords silver share Silver Mines Ltd (ASX: SVL) isn't joining in the rally.

Silver Mines shares closed yesterday trading for 23 cents. In morning trade on Tuesday, shares are changing hands for 22.2 cents apiece, down 3.5%.

But don't feel too bad for longer-term shareholders. Despite today's slide, the ASX All Ords silver share remains up 177.5% this year.

Here's what's happening today.

Business people standing at a mine site smiling.

Image source: Getty Images

ASX All Ords silver share slides on project update

This morning, Silver Mines released an update on its stalled Development Application for the Bowdens Silver Project, located in New South Wales.

In August 2024, the NSW Court of Appeal voided the project's approval, upholding legal challenges based on environmental concerns and issues with the project's permit and planning process.

The ASX All Ords silver share said it has since "been working tirelessly" to prepare and finalise all the required information for the redetermination of the Bowdens Project.

In engaging with the NSW Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure planning approvals system, the miner said it has decided to refresh its ecological surveys and provide an updated biodiversity assessment for the project.

Silver Mines noted that the redetermination of the Bowdens Project Development Application remains subject to a changing regulatory landscape, much of which is beyond its own control, making it difficult to forecast a precise timeline.

What did management say?

Commenting on the project update that looks to be pressuring the ASX All Ords silver share today, Silver Mines managing director Jo Battershill said, "Since the court decision in August 2024, the company has remained strongly focused on advancing the redetermination of the Bowdens Project Development Application."

Battershill noted, "The overwhelming objective has been to achieve the most appropriate and lowest-risk outcome through the redetermination process."

He added:

The result of this has been for the company to agree to refreshing its ecological surveys and prepare an updated biodiversity assessment in accordance with the Biodiversity Conservation Act. While this approach extends the overall assessment timeframe, we believe it positions the Bowdens Project on a stronger footing for a successful and robust redetermination.

And Battershill assured investors that the company remains fully committed to developing this core asset.

He concluded:

The Bowdens Project remains a high-quality project of state and regional significance, and development of it remains our top priority. We remain confident in the underlying merits of the Bowdens Project and are fully committed to progressing it through the approvals process in a thorough and transparent manner.

Motley Fool contributor Bernd Struben has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Resources Shares

Woman and man worker in quarry on excavation machine looking at a clipboard.
Resources Shares

What do brokers tip for Fortescue shares over the next 12 months?

Are the mining shares a buy, sell or hold now?

Read more »

Two miners talking to each other.
Resources Shares

BHP shares fall as mining operations grind to a halt

BHP shares are falling again as another setback hits.

Read more »

a man with a hard hat and high visibility vest stands with a clipboard and pen in front of a large pile of rock at a mining site.
Resources Shares

Whitehaven Coal vs New Hope: Which ASX coal share offers better value today?

Whitehaven Coal and New Hope go head-to-head: which ASX coal stock offers better value, income, and momentum for Australian investors…

Read more »

Young successful engineer, with blueprints, notepad, and digital tablet, observing the project implementation on construction site and in mine.
Resources Shares

Capricorn Metals shares: Karlawinda Expansion Project completes on time

Capricorn Metals has completed its Karlawinda Expansion Project on time, now targeting steady gold production and a decade-long mine life.

Read more »

A beautiful ocean vista is shown with a woman whose back is to the camera holding her arms up in triumph as she stands at the top of a rock feeling thrilled that ASX 200 shares are reaching multi-year high prices today
Resources Shares

Best performing ASX 200 stock is up 350%. Can it keep rising?

This share has genuine scarcity value, but it's still a high-risk bet.

Read more »

a hand of a man in a suit points a finger towards old fashioned brass scales that are not balanced in the foreground of the picture.
Resources Shares

Are the BHP and CBA share price headed for parity?

A leading fund manager has a surprising forecast for BHP and CBA shares.

Read more »

Two workers working with a large copper coil in a factory.
Resources Shares

Capstone Copper shares take off on $542 million divestment news

Investors are piling into Capstone Copper shares on Tuesday.

Read more »

Two miners laughing and having fun while using smart phone during their coffee break.
Resources Shares

BHP Group vs Rio Tinto shares: Which pays better dividends?

BHP Group and Rio Tinto both offer generous franked dividends—here’s which I’d choose for passive income today.

Read more »