Broker names 2 small cap ASX shares to buy for big returns

Big things could come from buying these small caps according to Morgans.

Key points
  • MotorCycle Holdings is experiencing strong sales growth, buoyed by the integration of Peter Stevens Motorcycles and strategic digital initiatives, leading Morgans to forecast a promising FY 2026 with a potential 20% upside.
  • Despite challenging industry conditions, MotorCycle Holdings is positioned for margin expansion and market share gains, making its valuation appealing at current levels with robust upcoming contributions from acquired operations.
  • Tesoro Gold remains one of Morgans' top gold picks, reflecting significant potential with its low-cost valuation relative to peers; its expansive resource growth could drive substantial returns, with a speculative buy rating and a potential share price increase from 7.2 cents to 32 cents.

If you have a high tolerance for risk and a penchant for small cap ASX shares, then read on!

Listed below are two small caps that Morgans has just given buy ratings to. Here's what it is recommending this month:

A man wearing glasses and a white t-shirt pumps his fists in the air looking excited and happy about the rising OBX share price

Image source: Getty Images

MotorCycle Holdings Ltd (ASX: MTO)

This motorcycle retailer could be a small cap ASX share to buy according to Morgans.

It highlights that MotorCycle Holdings has started FY 2026 strongly, with sales up 19% year to date. And with its margins rising more than expected, this bodes well for its earnings growth in FY 2026. It said:

MTO has commenced FY26 positively, delivering +19% sales growth (+6% organic; +13% inorganic) on better-than-expected gross margins (+85bps on pcp). The Peter Stevens Motorcycles (PSM) turnaround and integration process is taking shape quickly, with MTO driving a return to sales growth in October (+16% on pcp). Organic sales growth of +6% through FY26 (4 mths) was a commendable outcome given weak industry volumes through 3Q CY25 (-6%), leading to further incremental organic market share gains for the group (17.8% vs 15.5% pcp).

Another positive is that Morgans expects the second half of FY 2026 to be even stronger. It adds:

We view a stronger 2H to be driven by a full contribution of PSM (at a normalised run-rate); a seasonally stronger Mojo 4Q; and benefits from the group's broader initiatives (digital transformation; used volume growth; eCommerce) taking effect. Despite industry conditions remaining cyclically low from a volume and margin perspective, MTO has continued to improve the business, acquiring material scale through PSM, diversifying operations via Mojo, stabilising the cost base and driving organic share gains.

In light of this, Morgans has put a buy rating and $4.50 price target on its shares. This implies potential upside of 20% from current levels. It concludes:

We view the valuation undemanding (~11x FY26F PE; ~5% yield), with a material margin expansion opportunity ahead should volumes turn slightly more favourable. BUY maintained.

Tesoro Gold Ltd (ASX: TSO)

Morgans also thinks that this gold developer could be a buy for investors with a high risk tolerance.

In fact, the broker has named it as its top gold pick in the Americas region thanks to its robust production base case. It said:

We update our TSO model, rolling our valuation forward and adjusting cash position. TSO remains our top gold pick in the Americas, supported by a robust production base case and district-scale resource growth potential that offers potential step-change upside.

And even though its shares have rallied strongly this year, Morgans believes there's still potential for huge returns over the next 12 months. It has put a speculative buy rating and 32 cents price target on its shares. This is compares to its current share price of just 7.2 cents.

Morgans highlights that its shares are trading at a deep discount to peers on an EV/Resource basis. It adds:

While the share price has performed well, TSO still appears inexpensive relative to peers on an EV/Resource basis, trading at A$54/oz (vs A$176/oz peer average), and on a P/NAV basis at 0.2x vs the peer benchmark of 0.4x. We maintain our SPECULATIVE BUY rating, with a price target of A$0.32ps (previously A$0.27ps).

Motley Fool contributor James Mickleboro has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended MotorCycle. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Small Cap Shares

Small girl giving a fist bump with a piggy bank in front of her.
Small Cap Shares

An ASX small-cap share to buy for its bright future

Investors can get excited about this stock.

Read more »

Man with a surprised expression on his face as he looks at his computer screen.
Small Cap Shares

Could this exciting growth stock be set to triple? Morgans thinks it can

This stock is a must watch.

Read more »

Hand stacking increasing piles of rocks.
Small Cap Shares

Why investors should be targeting ASX mid-caps and ASX small-caps after earnings season: Expert

A new report suggests there is upside for smaller equities.

Read more »

A police officer points their detector at a speeding car.
Small Cap Shares

Why is this ASX small cap up 160% to get an ASX 'speeding ticket'?

Let's take a look.

Read more »

Five young boys wearing small caps sit on a bench together watching a baseball game.
Small Cap Shares

2 ASX small-cap shares to buy and 1 to sell: Experts

The ASX Small Ords Index is down 9% in 2026 versus a 2% bump for the broader ASX All Ords.

Read more »

$50 Australian dollar note on top of a plant pot.
Small Cap Shares

This profitable ASX small-cap just posted record results

This unglamorous operator is building a surprisingly attractive growth engine.

Read more »

Construction worker celebrates success in a tunnel.
Small Cap Shares

Can this ASX small-cap share price keep running into reporting season?

While most of the local share market has gone nowhere fast this year, one small cap has left the benchmark…

Read more »

A man surrounded by huge piles of paper looks through a magnifying glass at his computer screen.
Small Cap Shares

2 ASX small-caps with 40% upside

These two companies are worth monitoring.

Read more »