Pilbara Minerals Ltd (ASX: PLS) shares have had a red-hot 6 months, flying 127% higher in that time.
For context, the S&P/ASX 200 Materials Index (ASX: XMJ) is up roughly 23% in that same period.
Like many lithium stocks, it has had a volatile track record over the last few years.
Changing commodity prices, oversupply, and EV demand have all influenced lithium stock prices.
Pilbara Minerals shares have swung between lows of $1.23 (June this year) and highs of more than $5 over the last three years.
This kind of volatility can make it difficult for investors to pinpoint true value.
However, the team at Macquarie have issued fresh analysis on Pilbara Minerals shares.
Let's see what the broker had to say.
Image source: Getty Images
Fully valued
Despite lifting its target price, it seems the team at Macquarie sees Pilbara Minerals shares as trading close to fair value.
The broker has a neutral rating on the lithium producer, saying the green shoots are recognised by the broader market.
It said the 1QFY26 results beat VA on production (+6%), cost, and price (+5%). Cash of A$852m missed VA due to a temporary A$50m working capital build.
We see PLS fully valued with implied spodumene price of >US$1,200/ t. However, gov support under critical minerals framework could shift PLS investment thesis with timing uncertain.
The broker acknowledged that year to date, the Pilbara share price has increased by 45%, against a 10% rise in spodumene prices and a 4% improvement in China lithium carbonate prices.
In the report released today, Macquarie said Pilbara is trading at a premium, partially attributable to its strong operating and project delivery capability.
Updated price target from Macquarie
Macquarie has increased its target price by 9% to A$3 on improved earnings outlook, but has downgraded the rating to neutral on valuation grounds.
Pilbara Minerals shares opened trading today at around $3.29.
Based on this price and Macquarie's updated target, the broker sees a downside of approximately 8.8%.
Elsewhere, Bell Potter has a price target of $2.65, and TradingView has a 12-month target of $2.47.
This indicates Pilbara Minerals shares are trading above fair value.
