Is it time for 'cashing in some gains' on Pilbara Minerals shares?

The pure-play lithium producer has seen a remarkable 12 months but could it be time to sell?

Key points
  • Pilbara shares have rocketed 125% in a year 
  • The company explores lithium from the Pilgangoora Project near Port Hedland 
  • This week Pilbara accepted a pre-auction offer of US$7,100 per dry metric tonne of spodumene concentrate 

The Pilbara Minerals Ltd (ASX: PLS) share price has exploded in the past year.

Shares in the pure-play lithium company have surged 125% in the last 52 weeks to $4.80 apiece as at Tuesday's market close.

So is now a good time to sell, or is it better to hold Pilbara Minerals shares?

A man sits nervously at his computer with his mouth resting against his hands clasped in front of him as he stares at the screen of his computer on a home desk.

Image source: Getty Images

Hold or sell?

Pilbara operates the Pilgangoora Project near Port Hedland in Western Australia. This is regarded as one of the biggest hard rock lithium deposits in the world.

Red Leaf Securities CEO John Athanasiou recently recommended investors "sell" Pilbara Minerals shares, citing the company's recent gains. Commenting on The Bull, he said:

The company's been benefiting from higher lithium prices.

In fiscal year 2022, the company generated sales revenue of $1.2 billion, a 577 per cent increase on the prior corresponding period. Investors may want to consider cashing in some gains.

Meanwhile, UBS recently rated the Pilbara share price as a sell with a $2.65 price target, my Foolish colleague Tristan reported.

On the flipside, Macquarie placed a $5.60 price target on Pilbara shares in September, as reported by my Foolish colleague James.

A recent federal government report forecasted lithium prices to rise in 2023 before easing in 2024.

In news on Tuesday, Pilbara updated investors on its latest Battery Material Exchange (BMX) auction. The company has accepted a pre-auction offer of US$7,100 per dry metric tonne (dmt) for a shipment of 5,000dmt of spodumene concentrate in mid-November.

Pilbara is also due to release a quarterly activities report next Tuesday.

Share price snapshot

Pilbara shares have soared almost 50% year to date, however, they are down 4% in the past week.

For perspective, the S&P/ASX 200 (ASX: XJO) has fallen 8% in the past year.

Pilbara has a market capitalisation of about $14.2 billion based on the current share price.

Motley Fool contributor Monica O'Shea has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Materials Shares

Two business men looking at financial data, charts, and graphs on a digital tablet and a laptop computer.
Materials Shares

Alcoa posts higher net income, sets sights on AliGroup completion

Alcoa reported third quarter 2026 results, with higher net income and progress on the AliGroup acquisition.

Read more »

A woman sits in a cafe wearing a polka dotted shirt and holding a latte in one hand while reading something on a laptop that is sitting on the table in front of her
Materials Shares

Orora FY26 earnings: Cans strong, Glass under pressure

Orora's FY26 results show strength in Cans but ongoing challenges for Glass, including a substantial non-cash impairment.

Read more »

Three people at a building site discussing a plan whilst eating.
Materials Shares

Fletcher Building posts higher volumes in Q1 FY27, residential lags

Fletcher Building posted Q1 FY27 sales volume growth in several key business units, though residential activity stayed challenging.

Read more »

A bland looking man in a brown suit opens his jacket to reveal a red and gold superhero dollar symbol on his chest.
Materials Shares

2 ASX lithium shares to buy with 38% to 120% upside

Bell Potter sees potential for these shares to rise strongly over the next 12 months.

Read more »

Female miner in hard hat and safety vest on laptop with mining drill in background.
Materials Shares

Why are Lynas Rare Earths shares crashing 6% today?

Are Lynas Rare Earths shares a buy, sell, or hold now?

Read more »

Businessman planning and analysing investment data.
Materials Shares

Forget PLS, this ASX lithium stock could rise 80%

Is this lithium miner about to roar higher? Here's what Bell Potter is predicting.

Read more »

Couple using their digital tablet together.
Materials Shares

Orica updates on North American supply and land sales

Orica secures key North American supply and updates on land sales, supporting future growth and shareholder value.

Read more »

Man analysing data on his laptop.
Materials Shares

Forget BHP and buy this ASX copper stock

Bell Potter thinks there could be big returns on offer from this stock.

Read more »