Why buying ASX dividend shares based only on yield can deliver poor results: fundie

Income investors would do well to look beyond a stock's trailing dividend yield.

| More on:
A man with a wry smile on his face is shown close up behind ascending piles of coins as he places another coin on top of the tallest stack representing rising dividends

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points

  • ASX dividend shares are in focus amid rising inflation
  • Income investors should look beyond just the current trailing dividend yield
  • Long-term shareholders may be getting higher yields on their investment capital than current share prices reflect

ASX dividend shares have come back into sharp focus for many investors in 2022.

That's largely because fast-rising inflation is putting pressure on central banks to tighten monetary policies.

And higher interest rates tend to drag on the rapid share price rises that many growth shares enjoyed over the previous two years. Share price gains that came amid historically low-interest-rate environments.

With the outlook for growth shares in 2022 muted in comparison, investors are keen to see some extra income dropping into their bank accounts, courtesy of ASX dividend shares.

But buying companies purely for their attractive dividend yields can be a mistake.

Look beyond ASX dividend shares' current yields

According to Rudi Minbatiwala, co-portfolio manager of the First Sentier Equity Income Fund (quoted by The Australian Financial Review):

We think income investors can benefit from changing their mindset about equity income investing. Attractive income from equities is delivered through the interaction of yield and growth over time, not yield alone.

Minbatiwala points to ASX dividend share REA Group Limited (ASX: REA) as a prime example. The global online real estate advertising company pays a fully franked yield of 1.1%.

A stock like REA Group is a prime example – its strong earnings growth over more than a decade has delivered an exceptional, growing dividend income stream to investors over this time. But this income stream is often ignored because income investors mistakenly only look at the stock's low dividend yield as a function of the current share price.

I know this may sound counterintuitive to some, but thinking about dividend income on a yield basis can deliver poor income on a dollar basis over the long term.

Indeed, atop its reliable dividend stream, the REA Group share price is up 137% over the past five years. And, despite tumbling 20% so far in 2022, the share price has gained 973% over the past decade.

"We look for the best investment ideas, regardless of dividend yield, to maximise the long-term income from dividends, and also use options to deliver the near-term income needs," Minbatiwala said. "This widens the opportunity set of what we call income stocks."

Current yields may not reflect your actual yields

Minbatiwala added that the First Sentier Equity Income Fund also "quite likes" building materials company, James Hardie Industries PLC (ASX: JHX).

The ASX dividend share pays a 1.2% yield, unfranked.

"While it does not pay a large dividend relative to its current share price, the most recent dividends are quite significant compared to when we first purchased the stock," he said.

The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended REA Group Limited. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Dividend Investing

A businessman in a suit wears a medal around his neck and raises a fist in victory surrounded by two other businessmen in suits facing the other direction to him.
Dividend Investing

3.4% dividend yield! I'm buying this ASX stock and holding for decades

There are a few things I look for in an ASX stock when I'm looking for my next investment. One…

Read more »

Two people lazing in deck chairs on a beautiful sandy beach throw their hands up in the air.
Dividend Investing

Suncorp shares tread water as investors digest 2026 dividend timeline

Here’s what income investors need to know.

Read more »

A pink piggybank sits in a pile of autumn leaves.
Bank Shares

4% yield: Is NAB's dividend safe?

An expert says NAB's cherished dividend might be under threat.

Read more »

A woman in a bright yellow jumper looks happily at her yellow piggy bank.
Dividend Investing

Experts say these ASX dividend stocks are cheap buys

Income investors might want to check out these shares for their dividends.

Read more »

Happy young couple saving money in piggy bank.
Dividend Investing

Forget term deposits and buy these ASX dividend shares in 2026

Analysts are tipping these shares as buys for income investors. Let's see what they offer.

Read more »

Close up of worker's hand holding young seedling in soybean field.
REITs

A 5.8% yield and 30% undervalued — time for me to buy this ASX 300 passive income star?

It's not easy to say no to 5.8%.

Read more »

A smiling woman dressed in a raincoat raise her arms as the rain comes down.
Dividend Investing

Top picks: 3 ASX dividend stocks for stress-free passive income

If you're after reliability, check out these income shares.

Read more »

Happy man holding Australian dollar notes, representing dividends.
Dividend Investing

5 top ASX dividend shares I would buy with $5,000

Let's see why these shares could be best buys for passive income in 2026.

Read more »