Big Four Banks. Big Gains?

What do you reckon was the average share price return for Australia's Big Four banks over the five years to December 2020?

ASX bank share price represented by white Piggy Banks on green background

Image Source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

I have a question for you, based on an upcoming article I've written for Money Magazine. What do you reckon was the average share price return for Australia's Big Four banks over the five years to December 2020?

While you're thinking, I'll give you a hint: The ASX 200 gained about 24% over the same timeframe.

Still not sure?

Here's an alarming stat: The worst performing Big Four bank, over that time, was down 48% (yes, fourty-eight!).

Still thinking?

Want the number for the best performing back to help you frame up your guess?

-4%

Yes. Minus 4.

Here's the tale of the tape:

Westpac: -42.3%
NAB: -25.2%
ANZ: -18.8%
CBA: -4.0%

Bottom line: Not one of the Big Four Aussie banks delivered a positive share price return between January 1 2016 and December 31, 2020.

And if you held all four in equal parts, your return was -22.6%. Remember, the ASX was up 24.4% over that same timeframe.
You would have underperformed the index by 47 percentage points.

Ouch.

Now, I don't want to pile on, here.

I know many of our readers and some of our members own banks. Some of you own a lot of them. For many long term bank shareholders, they might make up 40%, 50% or 60% of your portfolios. Maybe more.

I'm not here to kick an investor when they're down.

And I'm not revelling in your misfortune.

But I do want to give you a little tough love. See, I've been saying, for a long time, that I think the banks' best days are behind them. Industry consolidation is done. Interest rates are as close to zero as any of us should hope to see. House prices are through the roof.

The length of a standard new mortgage has increased from 25 to 30-year terms. Second incomes have inflated our ability to pay. Innovators and disruptors are nibbling away at the most profitable products.

The banks have had a stellar run.

They've done wonderfully.

But I think we've seen the best. Famous last words? Maybe. But ask yourself: Where does the next decade of profit growth come from? Which of the above tailwinds, now stopped, will start blowing again? What others will turn up? Because I'm buggered if I know.

I just can't see it. Maybe I'm wrong. But ask yourself what's more likely: Will the three-decade-long tailwinds suddenly start blowing again, just as strongly? Or will the good ship SS Australian Banking be sitting, listless, in becalmed waters in future?

I think it's probably the latter.

And let's take this a step further.

Even if I'm wrong, are they really likely to be the ASX's best performers over the next decade?

Nah, I don't think so either.

(And if you're thinking 'yeah, but the Capital Gains Tax', have another look at the difference in gains from those banks and the index between 2016 and 2020. You could have essentially paid CGT at the top concessional rate in 2016, bought an index fund, and you'd have had a lot more, five years later, even after paying the taxman.)

Look, as I said, I'm not here to rain on anyone's parade.

And I've made my share of investing mistakes, so I'm sure as hell not throwing stones from my little glass house. I'm just asking you to imagine what the future might look like, based on the prevailing economic and business conditions, for banks in particular, and the rest of the market in general.

Don't you, deep down, think I might be right? Should you sell the banks? That's a call you have to make for yourself. But I think it's a question you need to ask.

You don't need to suddenly buy speculative rubbish. You don't have to abandon sensible, thoughtful, long-term investing.

In fact, quite the opposite.

You need to embrace it.

And you need to look for tomorrow's winners, not yesterday's. The Big Four banks were certainly among the latter for many years. But I don't know they'll be atop the list of the former. The economic and market recovery of the past few months has been good to the banks.

Maybe… just maybe… now is the right time to think about what you should own, instead…

The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Share Market News

A happy young couple lie on a wooden deck using a skateboard for a pillow.
Share Gainers

These were the best-performing ASX 200 shares in March

These shares made their shareholders smile in March thanks to some very big gains.

Read more »

Businessman using a digital tablet with a graphical chart, symbolising the stock market.
Opinions

2 ASX shares I have been buying in 2024!

I’m a believer in the long-term outlook of these stocks.

Read more »

Stock market chart in green with a rising arrow symbolising a rising share price.
Share Gainers

Here are the top 10 ASX 200 shares today

It was a massive day for the ASX 200, with a new all-time high recorded.

Read more »

A man sits thoughtfully on the couch with a laptop on his lap.
Technology Shares

This ASX tech stock rocketed 60% in March! Can it keep on delivering?

After soaring in March, the ASX tech stock is now up 169% since this time last year.

Read more »

Broker Notes

Brokers name 3 ASX shares to buy now

Here's why brokers are feeling bullish about these three shares this week.

Read more »

A young man clasps his hand to his head with his eyes closed and a pained expression on his face as he clasps a laptop computer in front of him, seemingly learning of bad news or a poor investment.
Share Fallers

Why Burgundy Diamond Mines, Clarity Pharmaceuticals, EML, and Zip are sinking today

These ASX shares are ending the week in the red. But why?

Read more »

A young women pumps her fists in excitement after seeing some good news on her laptop.
Share Gainers

Why Mesoblast, Newmont, Pilbara Minerals, and Platinum shares are jumping

These ASX shares are ending the week strongly. But why?

Read more »

a young boy dressed up in a business suit and tie has a cute grin and holds two fingers up.
Opinions

2 of my top ASX 200 shares to consider buying before April

I would happily exchange dollars for these two shares right now.

Read more »