Afterpay looked good at first… but are the good times over?

At a time when retail is already doing it tough, is the Afterpay Touch Group Ltd (ASX: APT) really delivering value for its retail partners?

a woman

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Let me say upfront — for the absolute avoidance of doubt — that I don't think Afterpay Touch Group Ltd (ASX: APT) is doing anything inappropriate, in regards to its retail partners.

But I wonder, these days, whether Afterpay is really delivering value for the retailers who are paying — potentially — well over the odds for the service.

But let's take a step back.

First, I am full of admiration for the Afterpay team, and what they've achieved. To be able to get a huge swathe of Australian retail (and some nascent progress into the US) against the likes of Visa, Mastercard and American Express is truly impressive.

More so when you remember that our own Bankcard was closed down, because it couldn't effectively compete.

And the Afterpay sales pitch, at the beginning, was devastatingly compelling. Using early successes, the Buy Now, Pay Later innovator was able to demonstrate a sales uplift that was well and truly worth the fees a retailer would pay Afterpay for the privilege.

But that was then.

Now? Well, I haven't seen any internal data from either Afterpay or its retail partners. But let me paint you a hypothetical:

In the early days, when a retailer could..

1. Entice a customer away from a competitor;
2. Draw in new customers who didn't have any other credit options; and/or
3. Induce a customer to spend more, because, hey, they could pay later

… the retailer using Afterpay could make a (relative) motza

Now, many, perhaps most, retailers take Afterpay.

And far from delivering on 1, 2 or 3, above, many customers who now use Afterpay are existing customers, who aren't going to spend anything extra, and who simply think:

'Stuff it. Why pay now, when the shop will afford me the privilege of paying later?"

That customer isn't new. He's not buying anything more. But the shopkeeper is paying more than she'd have to if the customer paid in cash or by credit card.

The customer wins.

Afterpay wins.

And the retailer? Isn't it just possible they've been sold a dud, and are paying more (and making less profit) for the privilege?

Why wouldn't I take the $100 I was already going to spend at, say, Officeworks, Just Jeans, Big W or Fantastic Furniture, and pay in four $25 chunks, rather than upfront? On the face of it, I'd be mad not to — the money is better in my pocket for a few weeks, rather than someone else's.

And when I do… the poor old retailer foots the bill, for no extra return.

Maybe it doesn't matter anymore. I mean, which retailer is going to drop Afterpay once they start offering it?

And the benefit? I don't think it accrues to the retailer. At least not once Afterpay hits critical mass, and offering it is no longer a differentiator.

So, bravo Afterpay. It's used the forces of competition and consumer demand to build its business in a totally legitimate and above-board way. And it's built such a strong ecosystem, that many retailers are still keen to use it, lest they lose customers.

But, at a time when retail is already doing it tough, Afterpay might just be the great hope that, far from helping, ends up hurting the bottom line.

Who'd be a retailer, even in a buy now, pay later world?

Fool on!

Motley Fool contributor Scott Phillips has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia owns shares of AFTERPAY T FPO. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Motley Fool Take Stock

A man in a suit smiles at the yellow piggy bank he holds in his hand.
Motley Fool Take Stock

Why are bank shares up so much?

While we can speculate on the answer, I’m not sure the speculation is useful.

Read more »

Model house with coins and a piggy bank.
Motley Fool Take Stock

'Housing AND Super', not 'Housing OR Super'

Yeah, but a home is more important than super, right?

Read more »

A man wearing thick rimmed black glasses and a business shirt with red suspenders sits at his desk sorting through the earnings report of Nickel Mines
Motley Fool Take Stock

One big lesson from earnings season

There is a lot to take in.

Read more »

Australian notes and coins surrounded by a calculator and the word super spelt out.
Motley Fool Take Stock

A simple fix for superannuation

It's time to return Super to its original purpose, to remove the complexity and to stop it being used as…

Read more »

Legendary share market investing expert and owner of Berkshire Hathaway Warren Buffett
Motley Fool Take Stock

Buffett's latest thoughts on business, investing and Berkshire

Whenever Warren Buffett speaks, or writes, I pay attention.

Read more »

Businessman working and using Digital Tablet new business project finance investment at coffee cafe.
Motley Fool Take Stock

Ignore forecasts (and guidance)

Think like a business owner, not a speculator.

Read more »

Businessman at the beach building a wall around his sandcastle, signifying protecting his business.
Motley Fool Take Stock

Invest like a Roman general

Humility is something to be cultivated in all walks of life.

Read more »

wooden block letters spelling DCA
Motley Fool Take Stock

The beauty of dollar cost averaging

Because it’s Friday. And I’m going to cover some investing fundamentals. But you knew that.

Read more »