This could be a problem for the Afterpay share price

The Afterpay share price has risen by 178% over the past year. It has over 9 million active shoppers. Yet, many competitors are emerging to challenge its dominance.

| More on:

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

The Afterpay Ltd (ASX: APT) share price has been one of the great gravity defying shares of FY20. Although not the first buy now, pay later (BNPL) company in the world, Afterpay has definitely done it very well. It is head and shoulders above any Australian rivals, and is already starting to see early success in foreign markets, particularly the US.

However, The Australian reported yesterday on an unlisted start up called Limepay, which is already seeking to disrupt the BNPL business model. Limepay allows merchants to integrate an online payments platform with their own branding, and to add their own BNPL functionality if they wish.

So, what does this mean for the future of the Afterpay share price?

The battle of the business models

The secret to the Afterpay share price miracle has been a business model where supposedly everybody wins. Consumers with limited discretionary funds can purchase items using no interest instalments, merchants see an increase in sales and pay a small 3–6% fee. Seems like a good thing all round, doesn't it?

Limepay has a counter argument, and it may be right. First, vendors get it. The BNPL wave of short term credit has taught everyone that customers want instalment plans. So why should they allow another company to get in between them and their customers? Couldn't they just do this themselves? That would enable them to maintain a long-term relationship with their customers.

Both the Afterpay website and the Zip Co Ltd (ASX: Z1P) website have an entire catalogue of merchants you can buy from. So they have taken customers as part of a sale in one store, and targeted them with competitors' products. The longer I think about this, the more I think this could be a threat to the BNPL business model.

The Limepay model is to enable companies to do their own instalment plans, and works with businesses such as the Accor group, which uses the platform for its 40,000 loyalty members.

The Afterpay share price

The Afterpay share price rose by 178.3% over the past year. This is despite bushfires, a pandemic and a lockdown. At this price, the company has a market valuation greater than Santos Ltd (ASX: STO) and Crown Resorts Ltd (ASX: CWN) combined. Nevertheless, there is some justification for this.

Afterpay is the clear leader in Australia. In overseas expansion, its UK subsidiary, Clearpay, already has over 1 million active shoppers. Similarly, Afterpay announced it has 5 million active shoppers in the US, and a total consumer count of approximately 9 million. Across the entire business the company has reported 9.9 million active shoppers for FY20. 

Lastly, there was the recent stake purchased by Tencent Holdings Ltd, which holds at least 5%. Tencent is one of the world's largest companies and operates China's leading digital payments service, Weixin Pay. Although no specific plans have been disclosed to move into Asian markets, there is a lot of speculation.

So, what has all this growth delivered? In the company's unaudited release it reported total sales of $11.1 billion in FY20. Sales represent the transactions that have passed through the Afterpay system through whatever means. The company is forecasting a net transaction margin of approximately 2%.

In contrast, Tyro Payments Ltd (ASX: TYR) recently announced the company's total transactions for FY20, in just Australia, stood at $2o.131 billion. However, the transaction margin in this case is approximately 1%. Tyro is a payments processing company, not a BNPL company. The example is to illustrate the scale of the raw figures.

Foolish takeaway

In summary, I think the Limepay business model is likely to appeal to predominantly large companies that are well branded. For many small-to-medium companies the Afterpay association helps generate sales. However, this is only one of the areas where the Afterpay share price is likely to hit headwinds.

First, a raft of other competitors have already sprung up, such as the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA)-backed BNPL product, Klarna. The appearance of the Limepay model, as well as the number of BNPL competitors, highlight the low barriers to entry in the space. Second, Afterpay already seems to have roused the ire of regulators in Australia. 

While Afterpay is growing very fast, I see its current share price as totally overvalued. It may reach $100 as forecast by analysts at Morgan Stanley, but I do not believe it is sustainable. For instance, in raw growth alone, it had to expand across 3 continents to achieve a level of transactions other companies have been able to achieve within Australia.

Daryl Mather has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. owns shares of Tyro Payments. The Motley Fool Australia owns shares of AFTERPAY T FPO. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Share Market News

A happy construction worker or miner holds a fistfull of Australian money, indicating a dividends windfall
Share Market News

These ASX 200 mining stocks could rise 30% to 60%

Big returns could be on offer with these miners according to analysts.

Read more »

Scared, wide-eyed man in pink t-shirt with hands covering mouth
Share Market News

These are the 10 most shorted ASX shares

Let's see which shares short sellers are targeting this week.

Read more »

A man holding a cup of coffee puts his thumb up and smiles while at laptop.
Broker Notes

This ASX 200 stock's 'compelling valuation' makes it a strong buy

Goldman Sachs thinks a 50% return could be on the cards for investors.

Read more »

A man looking at his laptop and thinking.
Share Market News

5 things to watch on the ASX 200 on Monday

Will Aussie investors have a good start to the week? Let's find out.

Read more »

A miner stands in front oh an excavator at a mine site

3 reasons ASX uranium stocks can keep charging higher into 2025

I think the recent sell-down in ASX uranium stocks has been overdone. Here’s why.

Read more »

Red buy button on an apple keyboard with a finger on it representing asx tech shares to buy today
Broker Notes

Top brokers name 3 ASX shares to buy next week

Brokers gave buy ratings to these ASX shares last week. Why are they bullish?

Read more »

A businessman sits on a chair looking at a pile of chairs stacked up to the ceiling of a white empty room.
Share Market News

Here's how the ASX 200 market sectors stacked up last week

Consumer discretionary shares led the ASX 200 market sectors last week with a 0.36% gain.

Read more »

A man holding a cup of coffee puts his thumb up and smiles while at laptop.

3 reasons to be positive on ASX 200 shares in FY25 (and 3 to be wary)

Vinay Ranjan from Airlie Funds Management says we should ignore market noise and buy quality stocks.

Read more »