Better Buy: Amaysim Australia Ltd or TPG Telecom Ltd?

With government intervention in supply lines, rapidly approaching 5G, and a hotbed of competition, the Telecommunications Services sector of the ASX is an interesting place at the moment.

With government intervention in supply lines, rapidly approaching 5G, and a hotbed of competition, the Telecommunications Services sector of the ASX is an interesting place at the moment.

a woman

Amaysim Australia Ltd Capital Raising and results

Amaysim Australia Ltd (ASX: AYS) shares entered a trading halt on 22 February and will stay there until 28 February as the company issues new equity to existing shareholders. The Amaysim share price is currently down 40% on its high of $1.57 traded this time last year.

A challenger brand in telecommunications and energy with a market cap of around $200M, Amaysim is seeking to raise $50.6M from retail and institutional shareholders with the intention of restructuring debt and investing in expansion activities.

After debt restructuring, $17.6M will be used to invest in marketing, a new energy product suite, and upgrading the technology stack to support growth.

The top, middle and bottom line for Amaysim's interim results released 26 February are as follows:

  • Net revenue down 5.6% to $263M
  • Underlying EBITDA up 32.2% to $29.2M (up 11.3% to $23.5M under previous accounting standards)
  • Net loss after tax $4.8M

At the segment level, Energy profit increased by 27% and compensated for an 8% lower profit in mobile. Looking forward, Management forecasts operating EBITDA between $44-$48M (under the new accounting standards) for the FY19 full year indicating a tempered second half.

TPG Telecom Ltd's strategic frustrations

TPG Telecom Ltd's (ASX: TPM) share price has reflected the repeated strategic frustration the business has faced. First, in partnering with out of favour Chinese equipment provider Huawei to roll out the 5G network. And, expression of preliminary concern by the ACCC around the proposed merger with Vodafone Hutchison Australia. The final decision from the regulator is due on 28 March 2019.

As announced yesterday, 26 February, if the Vodafone merger is scuttled by the ACCC, TPG Telecom will be looking at a circa $228M impairment due to write-offs from the 5G kerfuffle.

Is Amaysim's strategy TPG Telecom's competition problem?

Amaysim has busily divested from the fixed line Broadband business in the past half year with a view to focus on mobile services.

Among other issues, the ACCC is considering whether fixed line Broadband and mobile plans may become increasingly substitutable products, particularly as 5G services arrive. That substitution could push Vodafone and TPG into more direct competition.

Amaysim is basing its strategy, and appeal to the market for capital, on the assumption that fixed-line broadband is not a requisite for packaging services to households. If the ACCC agrees that mobile substitute for fixed line broadband, TPG's merger plans could be sunk.

Foolish Takeaway

TPG's challenges could push short term damage to results and lessen the effectiveness of one of Telstra Corporation Ltd's (ASX: TLS) primary competitors as the 5G transition moves ahead.

Personally, I like the decisive action being taken by the Amaysim team, raising a quarter of their market cap and looking to combine telecommunications and energy into a complementary, customer friendly offering. The commoditization of mobile services makes the cross-sell with traditional 'household utilities' like energy a believable proposition.

Amaysim's share price may also follow the entitlement offer's discounts to cheaper territory. The potential upside certainly appeals to my inner small to mid-cap thrill seeker.

Motley Fool contributor David Fulham has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia owns shares of and has recommended Telstra Limited. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended TPG Telecom Limited. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Technology Shares

A male investor wearing a white shirt and blue suit jacket sits at his desk looking at his laptop with his hands to his chin, waiting in anticipation.
Technology Shares

WiseTech shares: 3 reasons to buy and 3 reasons to sell

Do you hold WiseTech shares in your portfolio?

Read more »

Couple using their digital tablet together.
Technology Shares

Could the WiseTech share price reach $50 in 2027?

I crunch the numbers to see what it would take for this fallen tech share to reach $50.

Read more »

Robot's hand typing on keyboard.
Technology Shares

Do these ASX technology shares have too much upside to ignore?

These shares are looking like a value play.

Read more »

Happy mum and dad with daughter smiling on couch after relocation to new home.
Technology Shares

Is Life360 one of the best ASX growth shares to buy?

I look at the forecasts to see whether the current share price could prove surprisingly cheap.

Read more »

A silhouette of a soldier flying a drone at sunset.
Technology Shares

Codan shares hit a new record high after the company predicts another strong year

Both of Codan's divisions are performing strongly.

Read more »

IT specialist using laptop in data centre full of server racks.
Real Estate Shares

Goodman Group vs Nextdc: Which stock is the better buy today?

Goodman Group and Nextdc are both ASX leaders in AI infrastructure. Which share is better value today? Here’s my verdict.

Read more »

Happy investor on tablet with finance graphs rising in overlay.
Technology Shares

Why brokers think Xero shares could surge 130% from here

Every analyst target beats the current share price, which is a striking signal.

Read more »

Man looking at digital holograms of graphs, charts, and data.
Broker Notes

Forget Xero shares! Broker tips this top ASX tech stock for 24% gains

This ASX tech stock has rocketed 143% in a year, and a leading broker forecasts another 24% of gains to…

Read more »