Pre-match commentary and stats
CSL owns the world’s biggest distribution network for blood plasma products and is at the fore when it comes to protein science research. This ensures a steady supply of new medicines and the distribution network to sell products, old and new, come rain, hail, or shine.
Meanwhile, Ramsay Health Care owns a collection of private hospitals in Australia and abroad. Just as the company started with psychiatric hospitals in Australia, they will form an important part of the international expansion (particularly in France). Indeed, the move into France seems clever given that the country is well insured by both private operators, and a public healthcare system.
|CSL||Ramsay Health Care|
|Market Capitalisation||$32.45 billion||$9.27 billion|
|Forecast FY 14 P/E ratio||22.13||28.07|
|Forecast FY 14 Yield||1.89% unfranked||1.83% fully franked|
|FY 2013 Cashflow Yield||4.15%||4.76%|
|Net interest cover||81.19||7.41|
Notes: Thompson Consensus Forecasts, and based on last FY reports.
When it comes to price, it is too close to call. Ramsay boasts a slightly better cashflow yield, and a better dividend, thanks to franking credits. However, with a P/E ratio of 28 compared to 22 for CSL, the hospital operator fails to put CSL’s defence under sustained pressure.
CSL turns the tables on Ramsay when it comes to debt. Not only can CSL more easily afford its interest payments, but it is less geared and has a lower debt/equity ratio. However, Ramsay holds up under scrutiny: after multiple shots at goal CSL simply cannot beat the goalkeeper who is dancing with the grace of Mexican star Guillermo Ochoa.
The score remains locked at 0 – 0.
Ramsay looks good after kick off thanks to strong growth prospects resulting from recent acquisitions (and the ageing population).
Before too long, Ramsay scores a goal with an excellent header from a corner kick.
1 – 0 to Ramsay Health Care.
However, CSL looks good too as its constant flow of products boosts revenue and the company’s competitive advantage grows with every passing year. Striker (and CEO) Paul Perreault volleys a beautiful cross, straight into the top right corner: the equalizer takes the star Ramsay goalkeeper down a peg.
And the score remains at 1 – 1 when the final whistle sounds.