Better buy, BHP or Fortescue shares?

Both ASX 200 iron ore giants have been paying record dividend yields.

Fortescue Metals Group Limited (ASX: FMG) shares and BHP Group Ltd (ASX: BHP) shares have been getting plenty of attention this year.

And for good reason.

With iron ore prices surging above US$200 per tonne from May through July last year (currently at US$136 per tonne), the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) mining giants have seen revenues and profits soar. And investors have been rewarded not just with higher share prices this year, but record dividend payouts.

At the current share price, BHP pays a 10.2% trailing dividend yield and Fortescue shares pay a whopping 14.7% yield, both fully franked.

Try getting that from your bank.

But for investors looking to add just one of the ASX 200 miners to their portfolios, which is the better buy? BHP or Fortescue shares?

ASX share investor sitting with a laptop on a desk, pondering something.

Image source: Getty Images

BHP or Fortescue shares?

For some insight into that question, we turn to Ord Minnett (courtesy of The Australian).

According to the wealth manager, Fortescue's operating track record beats that of BHP.

Fortescue "on balance is slightly ahead of its peers over the past decade with four upgrades and three downgrades" on its iron ore guidance, raising shipment guidance for the past three years, Ord Minnett noted.

"Fortescue's shipment guidance has been lowered only once in the past seven years, in FY19 due to the impact from Cyclone Veronica."

BHP, on the other hand, has had the same number of upgrades as downgrades, giving a slight edge to Fortescue shares.

"Overall, we still regard Fortescue as the best Pilbara operator, with recently increased FY22 shipments guidance of 185–188 million tonnes (Mt) looking achievable," Ord Minnett analysts said.

Fortescue's FY22 cost guidance is in the range of US$15.75 to US$16.00 per wet tonne.

Ord Minnett currently has a hold rating on Fortescue shares with a target price of $19. Fortescue shares, up 1.4% in early trade today, are currently trading for $21.

How has Fortescue been tracking?

So far in 2022 Fortescue shares have gained around 5%. That compares to a 5.8% loss posted by the ASX 200 and a 13% share price gain by rival BHP.

For longer-term investors, the Fortescue share price is up 330% in five years, compared to a 100% gain for BHP shares and a 24% gain delivered by the ASX 200.

The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Resources Shares

Woman and man worker in quarry on excavation machine looking at a clipboard.
Resources Shares

At $143, are Rio Tinto shares oversold or overpriced?

Find out where brokers expect the shares to travel next.

Read more »

a man in a business suit points his finger amid a digitised map of the globe suspended in the air in front of him, complete with graphs, digital code and glyphs to indicate digital assets.
Resources Shares

2 ASX shares tipped to grow up to 35% in the next 12 months

These stocks may have a very exciting future.

Read more »

Young businesswoman sitting in kitchen and working on laptop.
Resources Shares

Could the BHP share price return more than 10% in 2027?

The shares have already enjoyed a strong year, but I've been looking at whether investors could see more gains in…

Read more »

Businessman at his desk, looking seriously at information on his digital tablet.
Resources Shares

Which is the better buy, BHP or PLS shares?

I've been comparing two mining giants with plenty of growth ahead. Here's which one I'd rather own.

Read more »

Mining vehicle at a mine site.
Resources Shares

Monadelphous shares are up more than 20% in two days. Are they still a good buy?

The company's first-half numbers are looking good.

Read more »

Copper balls.
Resources Shares

Copper price to peak in FY27. Here's why and which ASX shares experts rate a buy

We reveal 5 ASX copper shares recommended by market analysts.

Read more »

Happy work colleagues give each other a fist pump.
Resources Shares

The number one reason I would buy Rio Tinto shares

I've been looking at where the biggest growth could come from over the next decade, and one area has my…

Read more »

A statuesque woman throws earth in the air in front of a rocky outcrop.
Resources Shares

Why have Liontown shares lost 77% since May?

The lithium miner’s shares have come under heavy selling pressure this year.

Read more »