Why did the IAG share price underperform the ASX 200 by 11% in March?

It was a rough month on the ASX for the insurance giant.

| More on:

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points
  • The IAG share price tumbled nearly 4.8% in March. At the same time, the ASX 200 gained around 6.4%, leaving the IAG share price underperforming by approximately 11.2% for the month 
  • The insurer's slip came amid devastating floods across parts of Queensland and New South Wales 
  • Additionally, an update on the second business interruption test case saw the company's stock slump 

The Insurance Australia Group Ltd (ASX: IAG) share price struggled through March.

Its suffering came as major floods wreaked havoc in parts of Australia and news of a second business interruption test case hit the market.

At the end of last month, the IAG share price was $4.38. That's 4.78% lower than where it ended February.

Over the same period, the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) gained 6.39%, leaving the IAG underperforming by 11.17% for the month.

So, what weighed on the insurance giant's stock in March? Let's take a look.

A man slumps his shoulders as he stands under his umbrella in the rain.

Image source: Getty Images

Why did the IAG share price struggle through March?

March started out rough for many Australians, with major floods hitting parts of southeast Queensland and northern New South Wales.

Understandably, this likely led some market watchers to wonder if the cost to repair damages would dint the insurer's bottom line.

IAG was quick to mitigate concerns, releasing a statement on 1 March saying it was too early to understand the true cost of the disaster. However, it estimated it could be as high as $95 million.

The insurer followed up on that statement the following week.

Then, it announced that as of 6am on 9 March, it had received 24,000 claims related to the weather event. It was estimated to lead to a $74 million damage bill – less than what was previously predicted.

Though, due to the storms and flooding, IAG increased its financial year 2022 net natural perils claims cost from $1.045 billion to approximately $1.1 billion.

Interestingly, despite falling in intraday trade on 1 March and 9 March, the IAG share price ended both sessions flat with its previous close.

An update on the second business interruption test case also weighed on the insurer's stock last month.

The company noted that, while it wasn't adjusting its $1,222 million net provision for business interruption claims, some indications made it believe a release from the provision will occur and will likely be recognised over time.

The IAG share price slumped 1.3% the day the update was released.

What else happened last month?

The company also made headlines last month with reports claiming it's being taken to Federal Court to face around $300 million of claims.

The legal action was reportedly spurred by the company's now-sold 50% stake in Bond and Credit Co.

Bond and Credit Co is an insurer. It's said to have sold credit policies to cover entities related to the now-defunct Greensill Capital.

Previously, IAG stated it had no exposure to the credit policies. Commenting on the matter last month, an IAG spokesperson said the company's stance hadn't changed and it was anticipating litigation.

It's unlikely the reports budged the IAG share price. Though, they might have shaken some market watchers' confidence in the company.

IAG share price snapshot

The IAG share price underperformed the ASX last month. However, it's been ultimately trading in line with the index in 2022.

As of the end of March, the IAG share price was 1.79% lower than its previous close. At that same point, the ASX 200 had slipped 1.19% year to date.

Right now, shares in IAG are trading for 8.8% less than they were last year. Meanwhile, the ASX 200 has gained 9.9% over the last 12 months.

Motley Fool contributor Brooke Cooper has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia owns and has recommended Insurance Australia Group Limited. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Financial Shares

Happy investor on tablet with finance graphs rising in overlay.
Financial Shares

AMP shares have nearly doubled. Could China send them even higher?

AMP's China growth could fuel another leg higher for shares.

Read more »

Happy shareholders clap and smile as they listen to a company earnings report.
Financial Shares

L1 Group FY26 profit leaps 97% in first post-merger result

L1 Group's profit jumps 97% and FUM rises in its first year after merging with Platinum Asset Management.

Read more »

A group of businesspeople clapping.
Financial Shares

L1 Group's new PXC Advisors venture delivers 51% return since inception

L1 Group unveiled PXC Advisors as a joint venture, with its new strategy posting annualised 51% returns ahead of an…

Read more »

A couple sit in front of a laptop reading ASX shares news articles and learning about ASX 200 bargain buys
Financial Shares

QBE Insurance Group posts higher profit and lifts dividend in 1H26

QBE Insurance Group increased first-half profit and its dividend amid premium growth and a robust capital position.

Read more »

Stock market board with green numbers.
Financial Shares

Bell Financial Group posts record 1H26 profit

Bell Financial Group delivered record 1H26 earnings, thanks to higher trading volumes and new platform launches.

Read more »

A woman with a sad face stands under a shredded umbrella in a grey thunderstorm.
Earnings Results

IAG shares dive 7% on FY26 results despite $1.3B increase in gross written premiums

Net profit fell despite a $1.3B rise in gross written insurance premiums last financial year.

Read more »

A briefcase full of money
Financial Shares

PM Capital Global Opportunities Fund completes $221m capital raising, launches SPP

PM Capital Global Opportunities Fund has announced the successful completion of a $221 million capital raising and launched a new…

Read more »

A view through a glass wall into a board room where people are sitting in chairs around a long table, some with their backs to the front of the picture, others racing the front.
Financial Shares

FleetPartners opens due diligence to would-be buyers as Board considers proposals

FleetPartners is offering limited due diligence to three potential bidders, but shareholders need not act yet as no firm offers…

Read more »