Why is WAM Capital (ASX:WAM) underperforming the ASX 200 in 2021?

WAM Capital might not have lived up to its reputation in 2021 so far….

WAM Capital Ltd (ASX: WAM) has long been one of the most prominent Listed Investment Companies (LICs) on the ASX boards.

One reason would be its monstrous size, with a market capitalisation of almost $2 billion. But since its inception in 1999, WAM Capital has carved out a reputation for itself that is rather different from other famous ASX LICs as well.

concerned and worried man looking at computer and monitoring falling share price

Image source: Getty Images

WAM Capital: A different kind of ASX LIC?

The venerated Argo Investments Limited (ASX: ARG) and Australian Foundation Investment Co Ltd (ASX: AFI) have built a reputation over many decades as LICs that offer large, diversified portfolios of ASX shares offering steady dividend payments.

But WAM Capital instead went for a more aggressive investing strategy. This LIC doesn't usually do 'buy and hold' investing. Instead, it "provides investors with exposure to an actively managed diversified portfolio of undervalued growth companies". As well as "relative value arbitrage and market mispricing opportunities".

This strategy has worked very well for WAM Capital since its ASX debut more than 2 decades ago. According to Wilson Asset Management (the 'WAM' in WAM Capital), this LIC has managed to return an average of 16.5% per annum (before fees and taxes) since its inception in August 1999.

That's well above what the S&P/ASX 200 Accumulation Index has delivered over the same period (according to WAM, 8.7% per annum).

But year to date in 2021 so far, the picture certainly looks a lot less rosy. Take into account just WAM Capital's share price. We can see it remains down year to date, having lost 0.9% of its value since the beginning of January.

Now we won't be unfair to WAM Capital here. The LIC has also paid a hefty 7.75 cents per share dividend in 2021 back in June. That dividend is worth a trailing yield of 3.51% just by itself on WAM's recent share price (or 7.01% annualised). That would push it into positive territory for the year so far.

However, the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) has seen gains of 12.37% in 2021. And that's not even including dividend returns. This means that, even if we include WAM Capital's dividend, it's still trailing the broader market over the year to date.

So why this underperformance?

Share price vs NTA

Well, it's not as bad as you might initially think. With LICs, there are normally two metrics we can look at to assess the company's performance. Those are share price appreciation (duh) and net tangible asset (NTA) appreciation.

See, LICs hold within them a portfolio of shares. Many investors like to look at the raw portfolio value, or NTA, of a LIC's portfolio, rather than its market-determined capitalisation. That's because a LIC can either trade at a premium or a discount to what its actual NTA is.

We see this in action with WAM Capital. As of 31 July, WAM tells us that WAM Capital had an NTA per share of just $1.89. Yet it trades today with a share price of $2.21. That means for every share you are paying $2.21 for, you are actually only getting $1.89 worth of underlying share value. In other words, WAM Capital shares are currently trading for an almost 17% premium to what its underlying shares are worth.

Now although WAM Capital's share price has depreciated by 0.9% in 2021 so far, its NTA per share is actually up by around 5% between 31 December 2020 and 31 July 2021. But investors seem to have narrowed WAM Capital's NTA-share price gap rather than send WAM Capital shares even higher.

Why has WAM Capital trailed the ASX 200 in 2021?

So this premium to NTA that WAM Capital is currently exhibiting may be holding back its share price performance in 2021 so far. But even so, WAM Capital's NTA growth has still not managed to match the ASX 200's. There's nothing to blame but the company's investment portfolio performance for that.

No doubt investors will be hoping for WAM to rediscover its old ways and deliver some market performance in the months and years ahead. At least shareholders can treat themselves with that ~7% annual dividend while they wait!

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Dividend Investing

Mid-aged couple looking at a laptop.
Dividend Investing

3 defensive ASX dividend shares to buy and hold

Looking for reliable income? These shares could tick a lot of boxes.

Read more »

Man holding Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
Dividend Investing

$5,000 buys 4,065 shares in an impressively reliable ASX dividend stock

This underrated business is a top contender for income.

Read more »

Man reading his emails on a laptop while relaxing on a beach.
Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs)

How I'd build the ultimate passive income ASX ETF portfolio right now

You'll never need to touch this passive income portfolio again.

Read more »

Woman with $50 notes in her hand thinking, symbolising dividends.
Dividend Investing

I'd buy these ASX dividend shares over CBA shares for income

CBA is not the first choice I’d choose for dividend income.

Read more »

A young woman carefully adds a rock to the top of a pile of balanced river rocks.
Dividend Investing

2 ASX income shares I'd buy for reliable dividends today

These stocks have fantastic dividend track records.

Read more »

Ascending piles of coins next to a wooden dollar sign amidst the sun setting.
Dividend Investing

If I invest $6,000 in CBA, BHP & Westpac shares, what passive income could I earn in FY27?

Each of the ASX powerhouses pays a regular passive income twice per year.

Read more »

Man holding out Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
Dividend Investing

This ASX share portfolio would generate $20,000 in dividends

This portfolio could provide investors with a growing passive income.

Read more »

Wooden clock sculpture next to piles of coins.
Dividend Investing

5 ASX dividend shares paying out better than 5%

If you're investing for income, these companies might be worth a look.

Read more »