Bitcoin isn't as 'smart' as Ethereum… and that's why I hold it

Isn't Bitcoin old and irrelevant now?

The price of Bitcoin (CRYPTO: BTC) is treading near its lowest level in the past 12 months. After failing to continue its rebound in August, demand for the weathered crypto asset has waned.

Today, Bitcoin is hovering around US$18,780, down a gut-wrenching 73% from its 52-week high. The harrowing fall has coincided with monetary tightening by central banks around the world. As a result, liquidity for this alternative has evaporated right in front of our eyes.

At the same time, greater scrutiny around proof-of-work (PoW) — Bitcoin's consensus mechanism — has increased awareness of Ethereum (CRYPTO: ETH) and its recently adopted proof-of-stake (PoS) mechanism. The Ethereum network now uses approximately 99.95% less energy post-merge.

But here's why I continue to hold Bitcoin… and no, I don't hate the environment.

A woman crosses her fingers as she flicks a coin into a fountain, hoping for good luck.

Image source: Getty Images

Why I still see value in Bitcoin

We have all seen them, the comparisons of Bitcoin's network energy consumption relative to whole countries.

According to estimates by the University of Cambridge, the network is currently operating on annualised energy consumption of approximately 93 terawatt-hours (TWh). This would put the decentralised blockchain's consumption roughly on par with all of Pakistan.

Though, I personally don't consider this a negative if there is something of a corresponding value from it. In this case, the value proposition is a highly secure, immutable, and deflationary form of monetary exchange.

For context, YouTube demands around 244 TWh per year — pictured below — and no one bats an eye. Why is this? Because instant access to a library of content at your fingertips has value… immense value.

Source: Ethereum.org, figures as at June 2022

In the same way, I believe there is a huge need for a means of exchange that is governed by a decentralised cohort, accessible globally, and eliminates the inequality-inducing economic problem of inflation.

But why not Ethereum? And I agree, Ethereum has great value in its own right — bringing decentralisation to all forms of finances. However, in the process of converting to PoS, I personally believe the network removed an important tangible aspect.

To be fair, Ethereum has implemented some highly sophisticated tech that should maintain network security. However, there is something to be said for a network — such as Bitcoin's — that is reliant on something that cannot be imitated, created, or destroyed… real and tangible energy.

I'm still in the process of understanding all the intricacies of Ethereum 2.0.

Simple and stable

Speaking of intricacies… another reason why I personally still hold Bitcoin is because of its relatively straightforward concept. As my engineering days taught me: the more parts, the more points of failure.

While Ethereum quite honestly needs to be complex to achieve its goal, a decentralised store of value doesn't need to be. And, quite frankly, if I'm keeping a large sum of money there, I don't want it to be either.

Each time a protocol undergoes a change, it presents a risk. Thankfully, Ethereum successfully completed 'The Merge' unscathed, but there were likely a few people sweating in the process.

In contrast, Bitcoin rarely makes substantial changes to its foundational code. Personally, this is another reason why I like it as an alternative store of value. It may not be as 'smart' as Ethereum, but it sure is reliable.

Motley Fool contributor Mitchell Lawler has positions in Bitcoin and Ethereum. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Bitcoin and Ethereum. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Bitcoin and Ethereum. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Cryptocurrencies

Gold Bitcoins lying on a global finance currency chart with arrows shooting higher.
Cryptocurrencies

Bitcoin tipped to surge past key psychological level

A major holder of the cryptocurrency says the market is turning positive.

Read more »

Panicked man with his hand on his head with a red Bitcoin symbol and arrow going down.
Cryptocurrencies

Why did the Bitcoin price just plunge 6%?

Bitcoin and Ethereum both just got walloped. But why?

Read more »

A man sits at his computer with his head in his hands while his laptop screen displays a Bitcoin symbol and his desktop computer screen displays a steeply falling graph.
Cryptocurrencies

Bitcoin is back below US$77,000. Is this an opportunity for ASX investors?

Three big falls, three very different businesses.

Read more »

A rich buisnessman buys luxury items with Bitcoin
Cryptocurrencies

Why is the Bitcoin price rocketing 16% this week?

Crypto investors have sent the Ethereum and Bitcoin prices soaring this week. But why?

Read more »

A smiling woman holds a Bitcoin token in her hand.
Cryptocurrencies

Amid big swings in the Bitcoin price, can the crypto really help diversify your investment portfolio?

Leading analysts sound off on the diversification benefits of buying Bitcoin.

Read more »

A man sits at a desk with a phone in one hand, his other hand on his chin and studies a computer screen in front of him with what appears to be cryptocurrency data on both screens.
Cryptocurrencies

ASX shares or crypto? Here are the benefits and risks of each

Which asset should ASX investors choose?

Read more »

A Bitcoin symbol atop a spring, indicating the uncertain direction of cryptocurrency as a commodity
Cryptocurrencies

What could spark a Bitcoin price rebound in 2026?

Three powerful catalysts could determine whether Bitcoin’s brutal 2026 downturn finally begins to reverse.

Read more »

Red arrow crashing in the ground with a Bitcoin token next to it.
Cryptocurrencies

Down 48%, why a Bitcoin price rebound may be off the cards

Will Bitcoin and Ethereum ever recover their 48% and 61% price losses?

Read more »