Which delivered better returns in 2024: Fortescue, Mineral Resources, or BHP shares?

Volatile commodity prices made 2024 a tough year for ASX 200 mining shares investors.

| More on:
Three miners looking at a tablet.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Last year was challenging for investors in ASX 200 mining shares such as BHP Group Ltd (ASX: BHP), Fortescue Ltd (ASX: FMG), and Mineral Resources Ltd (ASX: MIN).

The flailing Chinese economy remains a big concern, and there is uncertainty regarding how much stimulus will be introduced to prop up manufacturing, industry, and the property market.

As a result, commodity prices have been volatile, and as we all know, this has a direct flow-through impact on the earnings of ASX 200 mining companies, their share prices, and the dividends they pay investors.

In assessing whether Fortescue, Mineral Resources, or BHP shares delivered better returns in 2024, let's look at what matters most to investors: share price movement (capital gain or loss) and dividends.

On share price movement, BHP shares win

Unfortunately, there was no contest as to which stock delivered the best share price growth because none of them went up! Rather, the contest was in which one held up best during their collective downturn.

As the chart below shows, BHP shares did better than Fortescue and Mineral Resources.

All three ASX 200 mining shares lost value, but BHP lost less than the other two.

The BHP share price fell 21.5% to close the year at $39.55.

The Fortescue share price fell 37.1% to finish the year at $18.25.

The Mineral Resources share price tanked, with factors beyond volatile commodity prices causing a 51.1% dive to $34.25 per share by 31 December.

In a shock scenario that no one saw coming, founder, CEO, and managing director Chris Ellison resigned in November amid a company investigation relating to his personal tax affairs and disclosures.

He will remain the managing director for 12 to 18 months until a replacement is found.

On dividend payments, Fortescue shares win

In 2024, BHP shares paid an interim dividend of A$1.0962 in March and a final dividend of A$1.11 in October. This totalled A$2.6143 in annual dividends with full franking credits.

Fortescue shares paid an interim dividend of A$1.08 per share in March. The iron ore pure-play then paid an 89-cent final dividend in September for a total annual dividend of A$1.97, fully franked.

Mineral Resources paid an interim dividend of 20 cents per share, fully franked, in March.

The diversified miner decided not to pay a final dividend later in the year. Management cited weak lithium prices and the remaining investment in the Onslow Iron project.

So, in dollar value terms, BHP shares win.

Arguably, the dividend yield is more important. So, let's calculate that using the ASX 200 mining shares' closing values on 31 December to determine which delivered the better returns.

The results are: 6.61% for BHP, 10.79% for Fortescue, and 0.58% for Mineral Resources, plus franking.

So, Fortescue shares did best.

Motley Fool contributor Bronwyn Allen has positions in BHP Group. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended BHP Group. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Resources Shares

A boy stands firm on a rocky cliff holding a rocket in each hand and looking up toward the sky, anticipating flying into space.
Resources Shares

Up 864% in a year, how this ASX mining stock is primed to keep rocketing in 2025

The ASX mining stock looks to be in a sweet spot amid export bans from China and Russia.

Read more »

Miner looking at a tablet.
Resources Shares

2 small-cap ASX mining shares exploding 40%+ on China tariff news

Investors are sending the small-cap ASX mining shares flying higher on Wednesday.

Read more »

a sad looking engineer or miner wearing a high visibility jacket and a hard hat stands alone with his head bowed and hand to his forehead as he speaks on a mobile telephone out front of what appears to be an on site work shed.
Resources Shares

Why are ASX mining shares falling this week?

The tumultuous start to the week for mining shares could be a sign of things to come. 

Read more »

Three miners looking at a tablet.
Resources Shares

Did you catch what happened with the BHP share price in January?

BHP shares saw plenty of trading action in January.

Read more »

Man standing in a mine with mining vehicles.
Resources Shares

Sayona Mining share price charging higher on 33% revenue boost

ASX investors are reacting very positively to Sayona Mining’s December results.

Read more »

A happy construction worker or miner holds a fistfull of Australian money, indicating a dividends windfall
Resources Shares

How does the Fortescue dividend yield compare to other ASX mining shares?

Fortescue typically pays excellent dividend yields, but can it do so again in 2025?

Read more »

Miner looking at a tablet.
Resources Shares

Forget gold! Why this soaring ASX silver share is still trading at 'good value' today

A leading expert has a bullish outlook on this rocketing ASX silver miner.

Read more »

Female miner in hard hat and safety vest on laptop with mining drill in background.
Resources Shares

As Lynas shares fall another 5% in 2025, what should investors do?

Let's see what the experts think.

Read more »