Too much of a good thing? When ASX dividends could hurt your overall returns

Dividends are a great source of cash flow, but are they the wisest choice?

A man sits uncomfortably at his laptop computer in an outdoor location at a table with trees in the background as he clutches the back of his neck with a wincing look on his face.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points

  • Plenty of ASX shares pay dividends to investors each year
  • But, a number of companies could achieve better returns if they kept that cash within the business, as evidenced by the return on equity measure
  • Unlocking franking credits is a worthwhile move for lower-taxed investors

ASX dividend shares are a popular investment choice for Aussies who want to generate investment income. But, there's an argument to say that it could harm returns for some businesses over the long term.

There are plenty of high-quality businesses on the ASX that are among the best at what they do, such as Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA), BHP Group Ltd (ASX: BHP) and Telstra Group Ltd (ASX: TLS).

Investors may expect a high level of dividend income from these businesses each year. But for plenty of companies, there could be better uses of money.

Growth spending is better?

When a business makes a profit, there's a variety of different things that the management could do with that money.

One of the most popular things for them to do in Australia is to pay a dividend. Investors like to receive a 'real' return. Institutional investors may want to get that cash out of the business – boosting their short-term returns.

But, that ASX dividend (yield) may only be worth a few percent in investors' hands. It could be worth less than 1%.

Some, or all, of that money, could be re-invested back into the business and generate a much better return.

A business could open a new, advanced, manufacturing plant. It could use the cash to open a few new stores in a new city/country. It could hire more sales people, or spend a bit more on developing the next product or service.

Some businesses can generate enormous returns on money invested in the business. This can be measured in a few different ways such as the return on equity (ROE) or return on capital (ROC). Those figures are good indicators of how much money the company is earning on the cash that has been invested in the business by the business.

For example, Wesfarmers Ltd's (ASX: WES) ROE in the first half of FY23 was 32.8%. It could make sense for Wesfarmers to retain more of its cash and achieve a high internal return, which would hopefully translate to a boost to profit, the share price and dividends down the line.

Berkshire Hathaway is a great example of what a great business (and investor) can do with retained profit. Warren Buffett's business has achieved a compound annual gain of 19.8% per annum between 1965 to 2022 – that's a total return of 3,787,464%.

The US giant has a policy of not paying a dividend because the cash is worth more to investors staying in the business than as a dividend. If it had paid a dividend, Buffett would have had a smaller money pile to compound, so it would have grown into a smaller amount over the years, even if he achieved the same investment returns in percentage terms.

Tax can also have an impact on the effectiveness of paying dividends. When a company makes a profit, it generally pays tax on that net profit. Not only has the company paid tax, but then the individual typically has to pay tax on the dividend too, particularly if they're in a high tax rate. The shareholder's wealth, on paper, can be reduced by receiving the dividend.

ASX dividends can make sense

There are some situations where it does make sense to pay dividends.

For starters, in Australia, companies generate franking credits – a refundable tax offset. It can make sense for the company to unlock the franking credits that it generates. For shareholders with a low (or zero) tax rate, the franking credits give investors an after-tax boost to the cash return.

Plus, a business may not always have a good opportunity to invest that money. That's why I think it's worthwhile investing in businesses that have lots of growth options. But, eventually, a business may not have attractive growth options. In that case, it'd be better to give out the cash than invest it badly or make a terrible acquisition.

For example, Wesfarmers shouldn't keep expanding its Bunnings network until there's a warehouse on every street corner.

I think businesses need to make a careful choice about what's best for the shareholder. But, I do believe it does make sense for some Aussie companies to unlock some franking credits for investors each year, particularly if that's what shareholders want.

Motley Fool contributor Tristan Harrison has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Berkshire Hathaway. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Telstra Group and Wesfarmers. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Berkshire Hathaway. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Dividend Investing

A mature-aged couple high-five each other as they celebrate a financial win and early retirement
Dividend Investing

5 top ASX dividend shares to buy right now

Analysts think income investors should be loading up on these shares.

Read more »

Two adults and a child look happy as they walk through airport with child sitting on suitcase.
Dividend Investing

Will Qantas shares pay a dividend in 2024?

Will the dividends return this year? Let's find out.

Read more »

A woman sits at her computer with her chin resting on her hand as she contemplates her next potential investment.
Dividend Investing

2 market-leading ASX dividend stocks to buy in April

Analysts have put buy ratings on these market-leaders.

Read more »

Father in the ocean with his daughters, symbolising passive income.
Dividend Investing

I'd spend $8k on these ASX 200 shares today to target a $6,102 annual passive income

I believe these ASX 200 shares will continue rewarding passive income investors for years to come.

Read more »

Man holding Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
ETFs

Want the latest dividend from the Vanguard Australia Shares ETF (VAS)? Here's what you have to do

If you want to bag the latest VAS dividend, here's what you need to do.

Read more »

A smiling businessman in the city looks at his phone and punches the air in celebration of good news.
Dividend Investing

Investing for passive income? Keep any eye out for that boosted Telstra dividend today!

If you own Telstra shares, keep an eye out for that juicy dividend payout today.

Read more »

A happy construction worker or miner holds a fistfull of Australian money, indicating a dividends windfall
Dividend Investing

Invest $12,000 in Woodside stock and get $5,700 in passive income

Reliable dividend shares are everywhere on the ASX. Here's how you could use that to your advantage.

Read more »

Australian dollar notes in businessman pocket suit, symbolising ex dividend day.
Dividend Investing

3 ASX 300 dividend shares to buy in April

These shares have been named as buys by brokers and tipped to offer very attractive yields.

Read more »