Revisited! Which is my best money manager to buy for big returns?

This article's advice from April 2015 was scarily accurate.

a woman

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Back in April 2015 I wrote this article on the topic of which were the best fund managers for share market investors to invest in.

For reference I am referring to the management groups themselves, not the underlying funds they manage that are also often listed on the local market.

Below is what I awarded the managers as investment ratings out of 10 in April 2015 and how the shares have performed in the 4 years since, not including dividends.

AMP Limited (ASX: AMP) rating 3 out of 10, down 67% since April 2015

BTT Investments now (Pendal Group Ltd) (ASX: PDL) rating 6 out of 10, down 24% since April 2015

Macquarie Group Ltd (ASX: MQG) rating 8 out of 10, up 45% since April 2015

Magellan Financial Group Ltd (ASX: MFG) rating 9 out of 10, up 110% since April 2015

Perpetual Limited (ASX: PPT) rating 2 out of 10, down 28% since April 2015

It's also worth noting that just because I am giving some of the fund managers themselves low ratings doesn't mean there's not plenty of smart people and strong money managers working at these businesses.

It's just that in my opinion the businesses as a whole are not as well set up as others to deliver good shareholder returns.

As we can see the ratings proved a good guide for investors as to what businesses to buy, although I don't have time to explain in this article what does or does not make for an investment grade fund manger, I have explained in some detail in plenty of old articles on Magellan or Perpetual for example.

Given this guide proved worthwhile in 2015, I'll update the ratings below and throw another couple of popular fund managers into the mix too.

So here are my ratings (with brief explanations as in prior article) as at May 29 2019, perhaps I will even revisit how they go in 4 years' time!

Australian Ethical Investments Limited (ASX: AEF) rating 7 out of 10, still a small cap, potential to grow institutional FUM.

AMP Limited rating 2 out of 10, well publicised problems, too bloated.

Macquarie Group rating 8 of 10, still a quality and innovative business, making a significant push into the green investment space.

Magellan Financial rating 9 out of 10, little more risk than Macquarie, but I expect could be the best performer of the bunch again over the next 4 years.

Pendal Group Ltd (ASX: PDL) rating 6 out of 10, a middle of the road business.

Perpetual Ltd (ASX: PPT) rating 3 out of 10, still struggles to attract FUM in part due to weak investment returns.

Platinum Asset Management Limited (ASX: PTM) rating 5 out of 10, outsources a lot of business development, which can make its low cost-to-income ratio deceptive.

WAM Capital Limited (ASX: WAM) rating 6 out of 10, focused on retail FUM, which is a weakness for investors anyway.

If we assume that only businesses you'd rate as at least 8 out of 10 are good enough to invest in then I'd still rate Magellan and Macquarie as the two stocks to own, with Australian Ethical as a fast-growing small-cap to consider that I've flagged plenty of times before.

Motley Fool contributor Tom Richardson owns shares of Macquarie Group Limited and Magellan Financial Group.

You can find Tom on Twitter @tommyr345

The Motley Fool Australia owns shares of Platinum Investment Management Limited & Australian Ethical. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Macquarie Group Limited. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Share Market News

A happy young couple lie on a wooden deck using a skateboard for a pillow.
Share Gainers

These were the best-performing ASX 200 shares in March

These shares made their shareholders smile in March thanks to some very big gains.

Read more »

Businessman using a digital tablet with a graphical chart, symbolising the stock market.
Opinions

2 ASX shares I have been buying in 2024!

I’m a believer in the long-term outlook of these stocks.

Read more »

Stock market chart in green with a rising arrow symbolising a rising share price.
Share Gainers

Here are the top 10 ASX 200 shares today

It was a massive day for the ASX 200, with a new all-time high recorded.

Read more »

A man sits thoughtfully on the couch with a laptop on his lap.
Technology Shares

This ASX tech stock rocketed 60% in March! Can it keep on delivering?

After soaring in March, the ASX tech stock is now up 169% since this time last year.

Read more »

Broker Notes

Brokers name 3 ASX shares to buy now

Here's why brokers are feeling bullish about these three shares this week.

Read more »

A young man clasps his hand to his head with his eyes closed and a pained expression on his face as he clasps a laptop computer in front of him, seemingly learning of bad news or a poor investment.
Share Fallers

Why Burgundy Diamond Mines, Clarity Pharmaceuticals, EML, and Zip are sinking today

These ASX shares are ending the week in the red. But why?

Read more »

A young women pumps her fists in excitement after seeing some good news on her laptop.
Share Gainers

Why Mesoblast, Newmont, Pilbara Minerals, and Platinum shares are jumping

These ASX shares are ending the week strongly. But why?

Read more »

a young boy dressed up in a business suit and tie has a cute grin and holds two fingers up.
Opinions

2 of my top ASX 200 shares to consider buying before April

I would happily exchange dollars for these two shares right now.

Read more »